Those are pretty trick little trailers. Since I am into streetrodding I like the
teardrop style. However in the NW camping with 3-5 people they are not terribly
practical. The extra room of Coleman is really nice when you have a rainy evening.
Then I'd look at a small 13-16 ft enclosed trailer. Rainproof and the
same weight as the travel trailer. A real bathroom and fridge, for
instance. Airstream makes a nice little model. Pricey, though - but
used, they are a fraction of their MSRP.
http://www.gorving.ca/manufacturers/rvtypes.asp?MID=T_Trailer&tit=TT
If you go down the list, several make tiny enclosed trailers,
which are superior, IMO, to a large tent trailer.
http://www.bigfootrv.com/traveltrailers/1500.html
Nice, but no real large bed for the adults.
http://www.bonair-rv.com/eng/travel_trailers/default.asp?m=BA16T
Not my cup of tea, but lighter.
http://www.bonair-rv.com/eng/travel_trailers/default.asp?m=BA14T
Itty-bitty.
(searches more - gheez what a lot of data - <3000lbs dry weight is rough.)
http://www.forestriverinc.com/nd/default22.asp?page=floor&choice=rk&nav=rec
The 2100 series ultralights are about 2800lbs. At 21ft long, it's
a big deal. Queen size bed in the 2104. So far, this looks like a
clear winner over a large tent trailer. The 2304 is nice as well - a
seperate room for the same weight. The 2108 seems to be the best floorplan,
but 2913 lbs is a bit much considering that's dry weight.
But all this time - I kept thinking - why not something small with
slideouts like a large tent trailer(based upon your weight, my guess
would be a 20ft+ tent trailer - likely a Coleman?)
http://www.forestriverinc.com/nd/default22.asp?page=floor&choice=surv&nav=rec
The slideout expansdables seem to be just what you are looking for.
Basically a tent trailer with walls over the main areas. If it rains,
at least you can get cozy inside.
The SV-191 and 210 are nice. 2700 and 2800lbs.
The 191T is better, with an extra bed. 2535lbs. Looks like a winner.
The 180 and 190 - the links are broken, but they are half a ft narrower,
so they should be even lighter.(scans PDF)2300 and 2700lbs.
IMO, a slide-out would be better than a tent expansion, but YMMV.
18 ft long and 2300lbs is very attractive.
Next is Jayco. I like them - my grandparents had two of them and
they were very well made. They drove from Illinois to California
at least 6-7 times in each before they got a new one.
http://www.jayco.com/html/catalog/product.php?prod_id=39
It's heavier than the Forest River ultralights, but is nice inside.
http://www.starcraftrv.com/
They make several types. Nothing says "cool" to me. Bland comes to mind.
****
Of these, the Forest River seem to be the best - lightweight, and you
can actually get a queen bed in a fully enclosed trailer(2104).
Same weight as the tent trailer you are considering. Of the
expandables, the Forest River Surveyor also is on top.
The 191T looks nice - it's light, has a second bed, and yet a double
inside bed as well(not a typical foldout on each end). The wide
floorplan also beats the rest - you can walk around in the center of it.
Evidently you can also get a bunk bed above the main one.